A joint letter for changes in the EU reform of the production and trade of plant reproductive material

More than 200 organisations representing the opinions of smallholder farmers, breeders, seed producers and environmental NGOs, including STEP, have sent a joint letter to the ministers of agriculture of the EU Member States, urging them to reconsider their position on the upcoming EU reform of the production and trade of plant reproductive material. The signatories warn that the current Council proposal does not allow farmers, breeders and seed initiatives to continue to preserve and develop crop diversity in Europe. On the contrary, it could seriously undermine some fundamental rights already recognised in various European countries, such as farmers' access to seed varieties adapted to their farming systems.

Organizations call for:

1. Exclude from the scope of the Regulation activities done for the purpose of the conservation and dynamic management of genetic diversity

Exchanges and transfers of PRM carried out for the purpose of breeding, conserving or dynamically managing plant genetic resources should not be considered as commercial marketing. These practices are essential to maintain diversity in fields and gardens. It is disproportionate and dangerous for agrobiodiversity conservation to be subjected to rules intended to regulate the commercial market.The purpose of agrobiodiversity conservation should be excluded in Art 2.4, as is already the case for exhibitions, research, breeding, and official tests. 

2. Guarantee farmers’ right to save, use, and exchange their own seeds, including with financial compensation

These practices have historically created rich agrobiodiversity, and allowed farmers to adapt their seeds to their own needs and support each other in crisis. As such, they are recognised under international law (ITPGRFA, UNDROP, CBD) and must be as well recognised by EU law outside of the scope of the PRM regulation. While we welcome the aim of allowing farmer’s seed exchanges through Article 30, we maintain that farmers who exchange PRM for breeding, conservation, and dynamic management purposes in the context of their agricultural production, and not for marketing purposes, should not be considered professional operators. Such exchanges are not marketing and should not be subject to the plant health and bureaucratic rules of marketing, but only to those applicable to agricultural production, allowing farmers to exchange PRM in quantities appropriate to their agricultural production needs.

3. Facilitate registration and use of both old and new conservation varieties for all crops and without geographical limitations

Conservation varieties are extremely important for many organic and agroecological farmers and breeders. Restricting them to a certain number of species or to their region of origin would be highly detrimental to those who currently rely on them. Therefore, those limitations must be removed, and their registration shall be simple, free, and accessible to any individual or legal entity. Plus, the definition must clearly state that these cultivars must be non-hybrid, non-GMO/NGT, and not covered by intellectual property rights. All varieties developed for growing under particular conditions (Article 21(1) of Directive 2009/145/EC) and commonly known fruit varieties (Article 7 of Directive 2008/90/EC) need to be entered as conservation varieties in the new variety register without further bureaucratic burden to ensure their continued availability.

4. Conduct Value for Sustainable Cultivation and Use (VSCU) testing under organic or low-input conditions

Sustainability cannot be reduced to single trait(s) or gene(s). Therefore, it must be assessed through a system-based approach. VSCU trials should be conducted under organic or low-input conditions for all varieties. For varieties suitable for organic production, the VSCU must be conducted under organic conditions for all species and in all Member States.

5. Reduce administrative burden for nano-enterprises to enable a diversified seed market and avoid its further concentration in the hands of a few main players

Contrary to the European Commission’s pledge of reducing administrative burdens for SMEs by at least 35 %, the new obligations for professional operators would considerably increase the administrative burden, forcing many small seed producers to cease their operations.3 Nano-enterprises, characterised by a turnover of less than 100,000 EUR, play a key role in making available a wide diversity of varieties and especially species to farmers and gardeners. To enable continued availability of regionally adapted seed diversity, nano-enterprises should be exempted from the new notification, administrative, and traceability obligations.

6. Ensure transparency on breeding methods and availability of information on intellectual property rights

Transparency, i.e labeling and establishment of public and mandatory databases on breeding methods and IPRs covering marketed PRM, is essential to enable informed choices and fair access. This ensures breeders and farmers having access to the knowledge needed to develop new, diverse, and resilient (organic) cultivars. It is therefore essential that the general breeding technologies used to produce a variety and the granted intellectual property rights are made publicly available in national and Union variety registers (Annex VII).

As the impacts of climate change intensify and crop genetic diversity declines, it is crucial that the new PRM legislation meets the needs of the actors working on the ground to conserve and dynamically manage agrobiodiversity, by making these critical key changes to the proposed regulation.

The Context

Diverse seeds and planting material are the basis of healthy ecosystems and diets, and resilient agri-food systems. They enable crops to adapt to local and changing growing conditions, resist pests and diseases, and support the production of diversified and nutritious food production. Strengthening this diversity is a key policy leverage for climate-change adaptation, ensuring farmers have the genetic resources necessary to cope with increasing climate variability.

Yet, over the past decades, agrobiodiversity has drastically declined. According to the UN, 75% of crop diversity in agriculture was lost in the last century, and 75% of the world’s food comes from only 12 plants and 5 animal species.1 This trend has been driven by a focus on uniformity and the concentration of the seed market in the hands of a few large companies. In addition, most cultivars have been bred under high-input conditions, and are thus unsuitable for cultivation under organic or agroecological conditions, which moreover require a much larger range of crop (and animal) species and varieties. Agrobiodiversity relies on non-commercial exchanges of PRM practiced by farmers and gardeners for on-farm breeding and dynamic management, as well as on small, local seed producers, many of which offer a greater range of crop diversity than some of the largest players in the market. 

The EU Legislation

On 5 July 2023, the Commission adopted two legislative proposals on the production and placing on the market of plant reproductive material and forest reproductive material. Plant reproductive material (PRM) is plant material (seeds, cuttings, trees, roots, tubers, etc.) used for the propagation of other plants. Forest reproductive material (FRM) refers to seeds, plants and parts of plants of woody species that are used for new forests and other types of tree planting.

The need to update EU legislation on these topics is necessitated by the fact that it partly dates back to the 1960s and fails to ensure a level playing field for operators within the Union. The outdated legal texts also fail to respond to the challenges related to sustainability, biodiversity and climate. The future EU Plant Resources Regulation should include strong provisions to reverse the current trend of decreasing diversity of crop species and varieties grown in the field. The unified policy should provide space for small and medium-sized breeders, seed producers, farmers and other actors committed to the conservation and dynamic management of a wide range of genetic resources that contribute significantly to the maintenance and development of agrobiodiversity.

See the original Joint Letter here.